VAL-B1-PMR-CNG-DISCOVERY · HISTORICAL FREEZE · 2026-09-20 · NOT THE LIVE FRONTIER

PMR CNG Discovery Scan

As written on 2026-09-20, before the unseen window was computed: substantial numerical evidence for a predeclared ε₁=37.5 oscillation, surrogate INVALIDATED, offline re-score UNCLASSIFIED_CRITERIA_GAP, confirmation still running. On 2026-09-21 that window received a narrow pass. This page keeps the discovery grades. D = FAIL and F = CRITERIA_GAP are not erased. The live frontier is now the 9 October scalar trace.

FREEZE 2026-09-20AS WRITTEN THAT DAY: SCAN NOT YET COMPUTEDLATER NARROW PASS 2026-09-21OLD SURROGATE INVALIDATEDF CRITERIA GAPD FAIL RETAINEDGLOBAL NOT ESTABLISHEDGATE NO

Checkpoint ladder

THEORY
Pointwise decay of F_reg required
NO
THEORY
Asymptotic structure
MIXED
THEORY
Global mixed-structure confirm
FALSE
SCAN
ω∈[9.8,10.3] Δω=0.01
51/51 ANGULAR_ACCEPTED
SCAN
ε_n predeclared / never fitted
TRUE
METHOD
Old surrogate discriminator
INVALIDATED
RESCORE
A nested H0 vs H1
PASS · R² 0.084 → 0.997
RESCORE
B dominant |P|
PASS · ε₁ 6.72×
RESCORE
C split-window phase
PASS · Δφ≈0.035 rad
RESCORE
D cross-half predict
FAIL · retained
RESCORE
E cross-component
PASS · θθ ~π-shifted
RESCORE
F smooth-null bootstrap
F_CRITERIA_GAP
RESCORE
Overall
UNCLASSIFIED_CRITERIA_GAP
WORDING
Numerical CNG confirmed
DO NOT SAY
NEXT
Confirm scan ω∈[10.40,10.90]
AS OF 2026-09-20: NOT YET COMPUTED · LATER NARROW PASS
LOCK
OUR_NUMERICAL_CNG_STRUCTURE_CONFIRMED
FALSE
LOCK
Abel / HH / GATE
FALSE / FALSE / NO

Layer	Checkpoint	Status
THEORY	Pointwise decay of F_reg required	NO
THEORY	Asymptotic structure	MIXED
THEORY	Global mixed-structure confirm	FALSE
SCAN	ω∈[9.8,10.3] Δω=0.01	51/51 ANGULAR_ACCEPTED
SCAN	ε_n predeclared / never fitted	TRUE
METHOD	Old surrogate discriminator	INVALIDATED
RESCORE	A nested H0 vs H1	PASS · R² 0.084 → 0.997
RESCORE	B dominant \|P\|	PASS · ε₁ 6.72×
RESCORE	C split-window phase	PASS · Δφ≈0.035 rad
RESCORE	D cross-half predict	FAIL · retained
RESCORE	E cross-component	PASS · θθ ~π-shifted
RESCORE	F smooth-null bootstrap	F_CRITERIA_GAP
RESCORE	Overall	UNCLASSIFIED_CRITERIA_GAP
WORDING	Numerical CNG confirmed	DO NOT SAY
NEXT	Confirm scan ω∈[10.40,10.90]	AS OF 2026-09-20: NOT YET COMPUTED · LATER NARROW PASS
LOCK	OUR_NUMERICAL_CNG_STRUCTURE_CONFIRMED	FALSE
LOCK	Abel / HH / GATE	FALSE / FALSE / NO

Dated correction, 9 October 2026. The chips below that say the scan was not yet computed are the 20 September freeze. On 21 September the same window received a narrow pass. Global structure is still not established. Discovery D = FAIL and F = CRITERIA_GAP stay.

FREEZE 2026-09-20 · STRONG EVIDENCEAS WRITTEN THAT DAY · WINDOW NOT YET COMPUTEDLATER · NARROW PASS 2026-09-21GLOBAL NOT ESTABLISHEDOLD SURROGATE INVALIDATEDGATE NO

As written on 2026-09-20: literature permits growing CNG oscillations after local subtraction, and a predeclared ε₁=37.5 oscillation is strongly present in the dense r=6M discovery scan. That day’s confirmatory scan had not been computed. On 2026-09-21 the window received a narrow pass. Global structure is still not established.

AS WRITTEN 2026-09-20: DISCOVERY → STRONG EVIDENCE · CONFIRMATORY SCAN → NOT YET COMPUTED · CNG CONFIRMED → NOT YET

01 · Literature expectation
ASYMPTOTIC_STRUCTURE_MIXED
Levi–Ori t-splitting subtracts only the local coincidence polynomial. Remote connecting-null-geodesic oscillations remain. Pointwise decay of F_reg is not required before generalized integration. Published envelope at r=6M includes ∼ω^{5/2} for the relevant RSET integrand.
02 · Discovery evidence
STRONG EVIDENCE
Dense angular-gated scan 9.8≤ω≤10.3, Δω=0.01, 51/51 accepted. Predeclared ε_n never fitted. Fixed ε₁=37.5 H1 explains R²≈0.997 of F_reg^tt. Dominant residual projection is ε₁ by 6.72×. Split-window and tensor-component phases cohere. Not confirmation.
03 · Independent confirmation
AS WRITTEN 2026-09-20: NOT YET COMPUTED
Frozen before computation: non-overlapping window 10.40≤ω≤10.90, Δω=0.01, 51 points, ε₁=37.5 fixed. That is the 20 September wording. On 21 September this pipeline recorded a narrow pass of the predeclared oscillation. It is not a global confirmation. See the confirmation study.

Plot 1 · discovery scan

F_reg^tt versus ω, 9.8–10.3

51 ANGULAR_ACCEPTED points. Solid: cubic + fixed ε₁=37.5 (H1, R²≈0.997). Dashed: smooth cubic only (H0, R²≈0.084). Frequency was never fitted.

Historical 20 September 2026 discovery freeze: 51/51 at r=6M, ω∈[9.8,10.3], substantial evidence for predeclared ε₁=37.5. As written that day, the confirmatory window had not been computed. On 21 September that window received a narrow pass. Discovery grades D=FAIL and F=CRITERIA_GAP remain. Global structure is not established.

OFFLINE_RESCORE_UNCLASSIFIED_CRITERIA_GAP · CONFIRMED = FALSE

Qualifiers

Do not say numerical CNG confirmed.
Do not flatten literature expectation, discovery evidence, and independent confirmation.
Do not retune the old surrogate discriminator.
Do not change F from CRITERIA_GAP to HOLD.
Do not erase historical D=FAIL.
Do not run Abel. Do not claim HH RSET. Do not flip the production sign. GATE = NO.

Correction chain

2026-09-19
Analytic audit GROWTH_EXPECTED_PRE_GI. Sparse 10/12 ANGULAR_ACCEPTED.
scan
Dense window 9.8–10.3, 51/51 accepted. ε_n predeclared.
surrogate
Old discriminator INVALIDATED_DO_NOT_USE_FOR_CNG_DECISION.
rescore
A/B/C/E PASS, D FAIL, F CRITERIA_GAP. Overall UNCLASSIFIED_CRITERIA_GAP.
next
As written on 2026-09-20, the confirmation window 10.40–10.90 was frozen and not yet computed.
2026-09-21
That window later received a narrow pass. Discovery grades on this page are unchanged.

Updated 2026-09-20. All checkpoints · VAL-B1-SCALAR-TRACE-R6 · VAL-B1-PMR-CNG-CONFIRMATION · VAL-B1-PUBLISHED-HH-CURVES · VAL-B1-HADAMARD-E-CANDIDATE · VAL-B1-PMR-ASYMPTOTIC-AUDIT · VAL-B1-PMR-ANGULAR-GATE · VAL-B1-MTAU-SIGN-REPRO · VAL-B1-EXTCOORD-HH · VAL-B1-EXTCOORD-PHI2-DERIV · VAL-B1-EXTCOORD-RSET-4PT · VAL-B1-HOWARD-242-246