VAL-B1-EXTCOORD-HH · ACTIVE PRODUCTION-DEVELOPMENT ROUTE · RSET HOLD
B1 Extended-Coordinate Hartle–Hawking Clean-Room RSET
Pre-RSET stack remains a historical pass under the implementation and tolerances of that date. October 9 found a massless-tail omission and a wrong static-mode boundary coefficient; those corrections are recorded on the scalar-trace page and do not silently rewrite this ladder. Ward, Howard 4pt, and four-point DEV remain HOLD. The 20 September confirmation was not yet computed; it later received a narrow pass. B1 is not claimed. The current trace claim is only the r=6M empirical comparison.
Checkpoint ladder
SOURCE / DERIVATION
TBO source provenance
PASSSOURCE / DERIVATION
Howard Table III source
PASSSCALAR
⟨φ²⟩ convergence
PASSSCALAR
⟨φ²⟩ derivatives
PASSTENSOR
RSET source assembly
PASSTENSOR
Synge reconstruction
PASSTENSOR
Direct TBO referee source
PASSTENSOR
Angular referee
PASSTENSOR
Trace
HISTORICAL PASS · NOT THE OCTOBER COMPARISONTENSOR
Ward
HOLDTENSOR
Howard 4pt
HOLDINSTRUMENT
PMR adaptive angular gate
PROSPECTIVE PASSINSTRUMENT
PMR sparse 10/12
ANGULAR_ACCEPTEDINSTRUMENT
PMR asymptotic expectation
MIXED · GROWTH EXPECTED PRE-GIINSTRUMENT
CNG discovery scan
STRONG EVIDENCE · NOT CONFIRMEDINSTRUMENT
CNG confirmation scan
NARROW PASS 2026-09-21 · NOT GLOBALLITERATURE
Mτ source/convention issue
EXTERNALLY REVIEWABLE · PAUSEDDEV
RSET assembly DEV
HOLDDEV
Four-point DEV
HOLDFRONTIER
Production grid
LOCKEDFRONTIER
B1 reproduction
NOT CLAIMEDFRONTIER
Physical gate
NOT REACHED
| Layer | Checkpoint | Status |
|---|---|---|
| SOURCE / DERIVATION | TBO source provenance | PASS |
| SOURCE / DERIVATION | Howard Table III source | PASS |
| SCALAR | ⟨φ²⟩ convergence | PASS |
| SCALAR | ⟨φ²⟩ derivatives | PASS |
| TENSOR | RSET source assembly | PASS |
| TENSOR | Synge reconstruction | PASS |
| TENSOR | Direct TBO referee source | PASS |
| TENSOR | Angular referee | PASS |
| TENSOR | Trace | HISTORICAL PASS · NOT THE OCTOBER COMPARISON |
| TENSOR | Ward | HOLD |
| TENSOR | Howard 4pt | HOLD |
| INSTRUMENT | PMR adaptive angular gate | PROSPECTIVE PASS |
| INSTRUMENT | PMR sparse 10/12 | ANGULAR_ACCEPTED |
| INSTRUMENT | PMR asymptotic expectation | MIXED · GROWTH EXPECTED PRE-GI |
| INSTRUMENT | CNG discovery scan | STRONG EVIDENCE · NOT CONFIRMED |
| INSTRUMENT | CNG confirmation scan | NARROW PASS 2026-09-21 · NOT GLOBAL |
| LITERATURE | Mτ source/convention issue | EXTERNALLY REVIEWABLE · PAUSED |
| DEV | RSET assembly DEV | HOLD |
| DEV | Four-point DEV | HOLD |
| FRONTIER | Production grid | LOCKED |
| FRONTIER | B1 reproduction | NOT CLAIMED |
| FRONTIER | Physical gate | NOT REACHED |
The pre-RSET numerical foundation (radial Green, Hadamard, Ψ⁺, ⟨φ²⟩, nested-h derivatives) remains PASS where previously validated.
Assembly machinery and trace checks have advanced. They do not promote the production RSET. Ward does not yet satisfy the full conservation/Howard gate. The displayed mixed-time derivative formula remains EXTERNALLY REVIEWABLE, not confirmed, and the Mτ lane is paused.
Do not flip the production Mτ sign. Do not assemble a 35-row Howard grid. Do not run Abel. A later PASS does not rewrite an earlier HOLD. DIRECT_LOG_5E3 FAIL_EDGE remains preserved beside DIRECT_LOG_1E2 PASS.
Qualifiers
- HOLD and LOCKED are not PASS. EXTERNALLY REVIEWABLE is not PASS.
- No truncated number is a physical value.
- This page does not launch the RSET burn, Abel production, author email, or a production sign flip.
Updated 2026-09-19. All checkpoints · VAL-B1-SCALAR-TRACE-R6 · VAL-B1-PMR-CNG-CONFIRMATION · VAL-B1-PUBLISHED-HH-CURVES · VAL-B1-HADAMARD-E-CANDIDATE · VAL-B1-PMR-CNG-DISCOVERY · VAL-B1-PMR-ASYMPTOTIC-AUDIT · VAL-B1-PMR-ANGULAR-GATE · VAL-B1-MTAU-SIGN-REPRO · VAL-B1-EXTCOORD-PHI2-DERIV · VAL-B1-EXTCOORD-RSET-4PT · VAL-B1-HOWARD-242-246