{
  "as_of": "2026-10-09",
  "purpose": "Public editorial handoff; not a runnable reproduction package",
  "locks": {
    "B1": "PARTIAL",
    "E_VALIDATED": false,
    "SIGN_VERDICT": "UNRESOLVED",
    "HH_INDEPENDENT_RSET_REPRODUCTION": false,
    "GATE": "NO"
  },
  "cng": {
    "date": "2026-09-21",
    "accepted_archive_status": "CNG_CONFIRMATION_PASS",
    "scope": "Narrow oscillatory-structure confirmation in this pipeline on the tested unseen window; not global asymptotic or RSET validation",
    "points": 51,
    "epsilon1_fixed": 37.5,
    "window": [
      10.4,
      10.9
    ],
    "C5_replay_date": "2026-10-09",
    "C5_method": "Joint source H1 A/B, then fit target cubic to data minus transferred oscillation",
    "C5_replayed_R2": [
      0.9988049064965255,
      0.9985764043986983
    ],
    "C5_grid_sha256": "3b85d57c14510e1c53b008e792860b9376e3236d55cdd5b4954e4bd26a6b0289",
    "historical_discovery_grades_preserved": [
      "D_FAIL",
      "F_CRITERIA_GAP"
    ]
  },
  "published_curve_comparison": {
    "source_date": "2026-10-03",
    "status": "TRUE_NARROW",
    "comparison": "Agreement within digitization tolerances",
    "values_agree": 12,
    "radii_M": [
      5.5,
      6,
      6.5,
      7
    ],
    "full_chain_label": "MRX_R_INVALID",
    "r5_v1": "ANALYSIS_R_INVALID",
    "supplementary_v1_1": "A11_C2P_PASS_ALL; does not replace v1 label"
  },
  "hadamard_derivation": {
    "date": "2026-10-07",
    "status": "E_DERIVATION_ONLY_CANDIDATE",
    "checks_passed": 16,
    "matches": "a,b,e exactly; c=d=0",
    "blind": false,
    "target_exposed": true
  },
  "scalar_trace": {
    "date": "2026-10-09",
    "status": "TRACE_R6_NUMERICAL_PASS_UNDER_EMPIRICAL_BUDGET",
    "geometry": "Schwarzschild",
    "state": "Hartle-Hawking",
    "mass": 0,
    "curvature_coupling": 0,
    "M": 1,
    "hbar": 1,
    "primary_radius_M": 6,
    "phi2": 0.00019571596066001755,
    "d1": -1.4850596580409429e-05,
    "d2": 6.65897313952517e-06,
    "box_phi2": 3.1414970956971594e-07,
    "scalar_inferred_trace": -1.2088044476173205e-07,
    "stored_PMR_trace": -1.2086496991741827e-07,
    "absolute_residual": 1.5474844313788875e-11,
    "scalar_empirical_allowance": 5.251546195221486e-12,
    "inherited_PMR_allowance": 3.856578844969775e-09,
    "combined_empirical_allowance": 3.861830391164996e-09,
    "rigorous_infinite_tail_bound": false,
    "statistical_confidence_interval": false,
    "retrospective": true,
    "target_exposed": true,
    "fitted_normalization_or_counterterms": false,
    "N": 24,
    "L": 48,
    "quadrature_order": 256,
    "scalar_sampling_radii_M": [
      5.92,
      5.94,
      5.96,
      5.98,
      6,
      6.02,
      6.04,
      6.06,
      6.08
    ],
    "independently_compared_trace_radii_M": [
      6
    ]
  },
  "next": [
    "Supported omitted-mode remainder control",
    "Independent trace checks around r=5.5M and 6.5M",
    "Independent tensor components, conventions, trace, conservation and PMR comparison"
  ],
  "source_documents": [
    "CNG_MILESTONE_FREEZE.md",
    "C5_AUDIT_PASS_JOINT_H1_2026-09-21.json",
    "confirmation_discriminator_verdict.json",
    "CONTINUATION_REPORT.md",
    "RESEARCH_PROGRESS.md",
    "TRACE_ASSESSMENT.json",
    "NUMERICAL_BUDGET_PROTOCOL.md",
    "CONVERSION_SPEC_v1.0.md",
    "ANALYSIS_SPEC_v1.0.md"
  ]
}